Dueling City
Welcome to Dueling City!

You should totally register and join our awesome community.
And yea, bring some cards because we have that weird habit to duel Wink


KCTAU on Steroids!
 

Share | 
 

 The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
AuthorMessage
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sat Sep 08, 2012 7:33 pm

Zenmaines' text says:

"Once per turn, during the End Phase, if this effect was used this turn: Target 1 card on the field; destroy it."

His popping effect in the End Phase can only occur once. If Zenmaines has detached a material this turn, when the End Phase comes, it tries to pop a card. Stardust is chained and tributed to negate and destroy Zenmaines, Zenmaines detaches another material to save itself (if any) and then Stardust returns on the field during that same End Phase. No second time popping for Zenmaines.

Credits go to Sylveraine on this one.
View user profile  
DarkFusion

New Member

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [DLK] Delta Knights
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 21
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 24
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 1
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : DarkFusion
Time Zone Time Zone : +1
Location Location : Macedonia

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 12:37 am

-sigh-...When it sais rules and rullings...youre supposed to answer a rulling some player asks....not start explaining what everyone knows...
View user profile  
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 1:49 am

1. Don't think everyone knows the rulings which you state as 'everyone knows'
2. At least I actually try to discuss something, not just complain about it
3. According to the description, the thing does not actually say 'Ask a ruling here and we'll discuss about it, blah blah blah'. So it doesn't have to technically start with a question now, does it nor does it state it should be asked by a specific person?



Hope that message gets cleared :3
View user profile  
DarkFusion

New Member

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [DLK] Delta Knights
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 21
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 24
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 1
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : DarkFusion
Time Zone Time Zone : +1
Location Location : Macedonia

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:10 am

No lololol what i see is your bad attempt to get posts and post useless rullings.Yes,everyone does know that stardust can even negate at end phase,yes everyone knows that zenmeines can only destroy once in a turn,and yes everyone knows that u need to detach cuz stardust does destroy.
View user profile  
Mr. Anzo

Administrator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [EX] The Exile
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 455
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 620
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : Anzo
Time Zone Time Zone : +3
Location Location : DA

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:22 am

What are you so mad about? lol
View user profile  
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:41 am

DarkFusion wrote:
No lololol what i see is your bad attempt to get posts and post useless rullings.Yes,everyone does know that stardust can even negate at end phase,yes everyone knows that zenmeines can only destroy once in a turn,and yes everyone knows that u need to detach cuz stardust does destroy.

Dude, the main point is that I'm trying to actually post something in here that is related to the section itself. You shouldn't actually complain because you yourself, haven't even made any attempt to actually post something that's useful. You keep on whining. Useless or not, at least I post something that can help newbies, unlike you. Don't compare everyone's level to everyone's that can't be even possible.

@Anzo: I'm not mad.
View user profile  
Mr. Anzo

Administrator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [EX] The Exile
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 455
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 620
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : Anzo
Time Zone Time Zone : +3
Location Location : DA

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 3:24 am

I was talking to DarkFusion.
View user profile  
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 4:22 am

Mista Anzo wrote:
I was talking to DarkFusion.

View user profile  
LethalAfterZ

New Member

avatar


1 warning
Team Team : None
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 36
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 40
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 0
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : The Great Poohdini
Time Zone Time Zone : +8

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 4:59 am

View user profile  
ALuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

New Member

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : None
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 37
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 43
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 0
Browser Browser : Chrome
DN Name DN Name : ALuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
Time Zone Time Zone : +2

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 5:04 am

Free city, do whatever you want.
View user profile  
pIrate

Moderator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [TR] Team Ragnarok
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 187
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 227
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 5
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : (space)Irate
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +1
Location Location : Vienna, Austria

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Sun Sep 09, 2012 11:52 pm

Zenmaines activates only once, even if negated.

Monster Effect Activations =/= Spell/Trap Card Activations
View user profile  
Mr. Anzo

Administrator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [EX] The Exile
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 455
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 620
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : Anzo
Time Zone Time Zone : +3
Location Location : DA

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Mon Sep 10, 2012 2:16 am

That's what the "Once per turn:" paragraph stands for.
View user profile  
LegendaryFrost

Judge

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : None
Academy Academy : [DGA] Dueling Genesis Academy
Posts Posts : 120
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 137
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 2
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male Age Age : 23
DN Name DN Name : LegendaryFrost
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +0

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Mon Sep 10, 2012 12:27 pm

ALuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu wrote:
Free city, do whatever you want.

True. But that doesn't mean we should post obvious rulings here, otherwise we could do that for the simplest of cards and the ruling section would be fully of nothing that could benefit anyone.
View user profile  
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Mon Sep 10, 2012 9:40 pm

LegendaryFrost wrote:
ALuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu wrote:
Free city, do whatever you want.

True. But that doesn't mean we should post obvious rulings here, otherwise we could do that for the simplest of cards and the ruling section would be fully of nothing that could benefit anyone.

Do consider that some players (Even I am sometimes like that, most cases when I tend to duel fast, hence becoming reckless with the rulings) tend to mistake simple rulings :/, especially the newbies.
View user profile  
Heisenberg

New Member

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : None
Academy Academy : None
Posts Posts : 13
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 19
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 1
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : HeisenbergST
Time Zone Time Zone : +02

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Mon Sep 10, 2012 10:29 pm

FYI; I didn't know that ruling.
View user profile  
pIrate

Moderator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [TR] Team Ragnarok
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 187
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 227
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 5
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : (space)Irate
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +1
Location Location : Vienna, Austria

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Mon Sep 10, 2012 10:36 pm

I will open a new thread in a few where you will be able to post any ruling you have in mind that people are most likely unaware of.

In that way, we can have a thread where everyone can look up rulings.
View user profile  
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Mon Sep 10, 2012 11:02 pm

pIrate wrote:
I will open a new thread in a few where you will be able to post any ruling you have in mind that people are most likely unaware of.

In that way, we can have a thread where everyone can look up rulings.

I think the rulings should be separated per category. For example: Coherent Summons Ruling Thread because if you post any rulings in just a thread, I think it'd be an ass time for others to search for the one they want when they want. Plus, it's more organized that way Smile.
View user profile  
pIrate

Moderator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [TR] Team Ragnarok
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 187
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 227
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 5
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : (space)Irate
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +1
Location Location : Vienna, Austria

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Tue Sep 11, 2012 2:41 am

Frances wrote:
pIrate wrote:
I will open a new thread in a few where you will be able to post any ruling you have in mind that people are most likely unaware of.

In that way, we can have a thread where everyone can look up rulings.

I think the rulings should be separated per category. For example: Coherent Summons Ruling Thread because if you post any rulings in just a thread, I think it'd be an ass time for others to search for the one they want when they want. Plus, it's more organized that way Smile.

Tell me more about coherent summons being a thing.
View user profile  
LethalAfterZ

New Member

avatar


1 warning
Team Team : None
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 36
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 40
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 0
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : The Great Poohdini
Time Zone Time Zone : +8

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Tue Sep 11, 2012 6:04 am

Please delete this thread.
View user profile  
Frances

Assistant

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [LGBD] Let's Go Down Below
Academy Academy : [MCA] Medieval Chaos Academy
Posts Posts : 633
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 810
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 12
Browser Browser : Chrome
Gender Gender : Female Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : Masked Phantom Puma/__ ! Wooie !
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +8
Location Location : Not for you to know.

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Tue Sep 11, 2012 11:22 am

pIrate wrote:
Frances wrote:
pIrate wrote:
I will open a new thread in a few where you will be able to post any ruling you have in mind that people are most likely unaware of.

In that way, we can have a thread where everyone can look up rulings.

I think the rulings should be separated per category. For example: Coherent Summons Ruling Thread because if you post any rulings in just a thread, I think it'd be an ass time for others to search for the one they want when they want. Plus, it's more organized that way Smile.

Tell me more about coherent summons being a thing.

Sorry, just saw coherent, I meant inherent x.x"

I'll lock this thread since it's starting to go off topic. Irate, do what you must then, lol.

Lastly, Heisen, +1 for your comment

Topic Locked.
View user profile  
Joco

Judge

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [EX] The Exile
Academy Academy : None
Posts Posts : 394
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 501
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 11
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male DN Name DN Name : Joco
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +1
Location Location : Hungary

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Thu Sep 13, 2012 12:15 am

DarkFusion wrote:
No lololol what i see is your bad attempt to get posts and post useless rullings.Yes,everyone does know that stardust can even negate at end phase,yes everyone knows that zenmeines can only destroy once in a turn,and yes everyone knows that u need to detach cuz stardust does destroy.

Not everyone - according to my admining experience.
However the majority of the this forum should know it.
View user profile  
pIrate

Moderator

avatar


No warnings
Team Team : [TR] Team Ragnarok
Academy Academy : [DA] Duel Academy
Posts Posts : 187
Contribution Points Contribution Points : 227
Reputation Points Reputation Points : 5
Browser Browser : Firefox
Gender Gender : Male Age Age : 21
DN Name DN Name : (space)Irate
Time Zone Time Zone : GMT +1
Location Location : Vienna, Austria

PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   Thu Sep 13, 2012 7:47 am

Frances wrote:
pIrate wrote:
Frances wrote:
pIrate wrote:
I will open a new thread in a few where you will be able to post any ruling you have in mind that people are most likely unaware of.

In that way, we can have a thread where everyone can look up rulings.

I think the rulings should be separated per category. For example: Coherent Summons Ruling Thread because if you post any rulings in just a thread, I think it'd be an ass time for others to search for the one they want when they want. Plus, it's more organized that way Smile.

Tell me more about coherent summons being a thing.

Sorry, just saw coherent, I meant inherent x.x"

I'll lock this thread since it's starting to go off topic. Irate, do what you must then, lol.

Lastly, Heisen, +1 for your comment

Topic Locked.

Please do not moderate topics outside of the moderation area you were specified for.

It's up to the forum moderation or to the assigned section moderation to do so.

Now... anyways...

Topic Locked.
View user profile  
Sponsored content





PostSubject: Re: The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon   

 
 

The ruling on Zenmaines vs Stardust Dragon

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

 Similar topics

-
» stardust dragon and return from diffrent dimension
» Stardust Dragon Vs The Seal of Orichalcos Cards
» Stardust Dragon Assault Mode Vs Continuous effects
» Stardust Dragon/Assault Mode
» Stardust Dragon ruling question.

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Dueling City :: Yugitown :: Rules & Rulings-

Forum Statistics


General Info






Online Users

In total there is 0 user online :: 0 Registered, 0 Hidden and 0 Guests
Most users ever online was 38 on Thu Oct 12, 2017 6:21 am

Users browsing this forum: None


DC Chat Info

 : 
User Presence



User Birthdays



Member Groups

 :